Hm... I don't want to ask everyone to do HW, but I do want to allow the option. If everybody involved is okay with it, perhaps I could keep a post (or a shareable google spreadsheet) with the 1-min clips as they come in and with a link to the podfic they're from, so nobody would feel uncomfortably on the spot if they are the type of person who likes to be prepared for something like that.

Of course, those who did prep would need to keep in mind to keep their comments short, because there would only be a couple of minutes to give feedback to each podficcer.

As for numbers, I could see it going either way, but I think we can play with time once we see how much interest there is and make it work regardless.